Hospital Charity Care Policies Often Misaligned With Community Financial Needs, Study Finds

Billions of dollars in tax breaks help support nonprofit hospitals across the United States. Still, a new study raises questions about whether their financial assistance policies adequately serve patients in communities struggling with poverty and a lack of health insurance.

Researchers at Tulane University found that hospitals serving financially disadvantaged areas generally maintained similar income limits for free medical care as those in better-off communities. The study, published November 2 in Health Affairs, examined a decade of Internal Revenue Service records covering more than 1,600 nonprofit hospitals.

Nonprofit hospitals receive substantial tax exemptions in return for providing community benefits. Those exemptions were valued at an estimated $37.4 billion in 2021. One important benefit is charity care, which provides free or discounted treatment to eligible patients. Yet hospitals set their own income requirements, with no uniform federal standard governing who qualifies.

“Hospitals receive large tax exemptions and are expected to reinvest in their communities,” said lead author Tatiane Santos, an assistant professor at Tulane’s Celia Scott Weatherhead School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine. “A key way of doing that is through charity care, which is especially important given the ongoing medical debt crisis.”

To assess community need, researchers examined the proportion of low-income residents without health insurance in each county. They discovered little difference in charity care eligibility between hospitals in high-need and lower-need areas. Income thresholds averaged around 180% of the federal poverty level, equivalent to approximately $60,000 annually for a family of four.

The findings revealed another distinction. Hospitals in poorer communities provided more charity care but also accumulated more bad debt from unpaid medical bills. Meanwhile, hospitals with more generous eligibility rules tended to provide greater financial assistance and report less bad debt. This relationship was roughly twice as strong in high-need communities, where broader eligibility was associated with approximately $383,000 in additional annual charity care per hospital.

Researchers also compared hospitals against a charity care spending benchmark of roughly 1% of operating budgets. Among those falling below that level, 461 restricted free care to families earning no more than twice the federal poverty level, or approximately $66,000 annually for a family of four. Another 168 imposed stricter limits of about $33,000, equivalent to the poverty level itself. Thirty-four of those hospitals served communities with particularly high concentrations of low-income, uninsured residents.

If the 168 hospitals expanded eligibility to twice the poverty level, researchers estimated that each could provide approximately $710,000 more in free or discounted treatment annually. Although relatively small compared with a typical hospital operating budget of $142 million, that additional assistance could reduce the financial burden on patients.

The researchers acknowledged that some hospitals, particularly rural facilities facing financial pressures, may have limited capacity to expand assistance. Others, however, could potentially offer more. With Medicaid cuts threatening insurance coverage and patients facing higher deductibles and copayments, Santos warned that demand for financial help could increase.

“Even in more affluent communities, people with insurance are struggling to pay their medical bills,” Santos said. “Medical debt is affecting everybody.”

More information: Tatiane Santos et al, Not-For-Profit Hospitals’ Patient Financial Assistance And Alignment With Community Need: A National Study, Health Affairs. DOI: 10.1377/hlthaff.2026.00268

Journal information: Health Affairs Provided by Tulane University

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *